Are Natural Ingredients Better for Skin?
Explore whether natural skincare ingredients are actually safer or more effective than synthetic ones. Science-based analysis of the natural vs synthetic debate.
The beauty industry has embraced "natural" and "clean" beauty as major trends. Many consumers believe natural ingredients are inherently safer and more effective than synthetic ones. But is this actually true?
The short answer: No. Natural does not automatically mean better, safer, or more effective.
The Appeal of Natural
Why People Prefer Natural
- Perception of purity
- Fear of chemicals
- Environmental concerns
- Marketing influence
- Distrust of synthetic ingredients
The Problem with These Assumptions
These beliefs are based on the naturalistic fallacy: the assumption that what is natural is inherently good.
Natural vs. Synthetic: The Facts
Natural Is Not Automatically Safe
Dangerous natural substances:
- Poison ivy
- Arsenic
- Snake venom
- Many essential oils at high concentrations
- Citrus oils (photosensitizing)
Safe synthetic substances:
- Hyaluronic acid (often lab-made)
- Niacinamide
- Many peptides
- Retinoids
Synthetic Is Not Automatically Harmful
Many synthetic ingredients are:
- Identical to natural compounds
- More pure and consistent
- Better tested for safety
- More effective
- More sustainable to produce
Examples That Challenge the Natural Narrative
Natural Ingredients That Can Cause Problems
| Ingredient | Issue |
|---|---|
| Lemon juice | Photosensitizing, irritating |
| Coconut oil | Highly comedogenic |
| Essential oils | Can be irritating or sensitizing |
| Baking soda | Disrupts skin pH |
| Apple cider vinegar | Can burn skin |
Synthetic Ingredients That Are Excellent
| Ingredient | Benefits |
|---|---|
| Retinoids | Proven anti-aging and anti-acne |
| Hyaluronic acid | Powerful hydration |
| Niacinamide | Oil control, anti-inflammatory |
| Ceramides | Barrier repair |
| Peptides | Collagen support |
What Actually Matters
Safety
Safety depends on:
- Concentration used
- Formulation
- Individual reactions
- Application method
- Scientific testing
NOT on whether something is natural or synthetic.
Effectiveness
Effectiveness depends on:
- Scientific evidence
- Proper formulation
- Appropriate concentration
- Skin compatibility
NOT on natural origin.
Sustainability
Surprisingly, synthetic ingredients can be more sustainable:
- Do not require farming land
- More efficient production
- Consistent supply
- Less environmental impact in some cases
The Clean Beauty Problem
Lack of Definition
"Clean beauty" has no regulated definition. Brands define it however they want, often excluding safe ingredients while including problematic natural ones.
Fear-Based Marketing
Clean beauty often relies on:
- Scaring consumers about safe ingredients
- Cherry-picking studies
- Misrepresenting science
- Creating unnecessary ingredient lists to avoid
How to Actually Evaluate Ingredients
Better Questions to Ask
- Is there scientific evidence this ingredient works?
- Is it safe at this concentration?
- Is it properly formulated?
- Does it work for my skin type?
- What do dermatologists say?
Reliable Resources
- Peer-reviewed studies
- Dermatologist recommendations
- Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR)
- FDA and EU safety assessments
The Bottom Line
The natural vs. synthetic debate is a false dichotomy. What matters is:
- Scientific evidence of safety and efficacy
- Proper formulation
- Appropriate concentration
- Individual skin compatibility
Some of the best skincare ingredients are synthetic. Some natural ingredients can be harmful. Judge ingredients on their merits, not their origin.
Want to understand what is in your products? Use SCRNE to scan ingredient lists and get information about each ingredient based on science, not marketing claims.
Sources
-
Draelos, Z. D. "The Effect of Botanical Ingre dients on Skin and Hair." Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, vol. 6, no. 1, 2007, pp. 2-6.
-
Cosmetic Ingredient Review. "Analysis of Natural vs. Synthetic Ingredients in Cosmetics." CIR Expert Panel
-
Nash, J. F., & Tanner, P. R. "Relevance of UV filter/sunscreen product photostability to human safety." Photodermatology, Photoimmunology & Photomedicine, vol. 30, no. 2-3, 2014, pp. 88-95. PubMed
-
European Commission Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety. "Natural and Organic Cosmetics: A Scientific View." SCCS, 2017.
-
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. "'Natural' on Cosmetic Labeling." FDA.gov